Cover vs. Cover: Which One Will Reign Supreme??

SO someone on Reddit offered to do a new cover for Shifter In Ascent, and I agreed to see a potential cover. (The Redditor is stfuminjakid in case you were wondering.) Anyway, he sent me a tentative cover (with the wrong title information, but ignore that). I wanted to post this and see which one Y'ALL liked best, and see if you had any tips or comments!!

Current Cover:

Potential Cover:

Old, new, or none of the above???